Allstate to Launch Online Sales
Of Auto and Home Insurance
By DEBORAH LOHSE
Staff Reporter of THE WALL STREET JOURNAL
You can be in good virtual hands, too, Allstate Corp. is betting.
In a strategic shift that will cost more than $1 billion over two years,
the big
insurer plans to begin selling car and home insurance directly to consumers
through the Internet and over the telephone. It is a revolutionary move
for a
company with a huge, nationwide fleet of sales agents. And it is the latest
example of a traditional, "bricks-and-mortar" company being pulled on to
the Web.
Allstate will finance its ambitious Web and phone strategy partly by cutting
costs. The company will eliminate 10% of its nonagent work force, slashing
4,000 positions, for annual savings of $600 million.
"It's a very competitive marketplace out there right now," Allstate
Chairman and Chief Executive Edward Liddy said in an interview. The
industry leaders nowadays are those that have "the lowest cost structure,"
he said.
Radical Departure
The direct-sales initiative represents a stark departure for a company
that
traditionally focused mainly on reaching customers through a huge fleet
of
agents who generate sales for Allstate. "It's a bold move" for the company,
said Jay Cohen, a property-casualty analyst with Merrill Lynch & Co.
"They are totally changing the model" for property-casualty insurers.
A Changing State
Allstate responds to Web challenge
Initiatives
Spend about $1 billion over
two years to launch an
Internet and phone sales
channel.
Cut 10% of its non-agent
workforce, or 4,000
positions, to save $600
million.
Convert 6,500 employee
agents to independent
contractors.
Buy back $3 billion in additional shares.
Sources: The company; Tradeline
Still, Allstate isn't going to cut agents completely out of the picture.
Any
customer reaching Allstate via the phone or the Internet will be assigned
an
Allstate agent, who will get a 2% to 3.5% commission on any product that
customer buys through that channel; that compares with the 10%
commission an agent earns for business he generated.
Allstate plans to begin offering phone and Internet sales gradually, starting
with customers in Oregon in the spring, expanding to 16 states over the
next year and nationwide by 2001. It plans to market Internet-sold
products using the Allstate name. In the past, the company used newly
created brand names when trying new forms of distribution.
Response to Rivals
The move, reflecting the giant insurer's struggle to stay competitive,
is an
effort to grab some of the success that nimble rivals such as Progressive
Corp. and Geico, part of Berkshire Hathaway, have enjoyed as they target
customers directly, bypassing costly agents. When such direct-sales
operations are up and running with critical mass, they can result in
lower-cost insurance. Progressive and Geico have posted double-digit
premium growth, while premium growth in Allstate's core business has
been anemic.
Every company is waking up to the realization that they must have "multiple
access points to the customer," said Larry Mayewski, an analyst with
A.M. Best Co.
Allstate said it will plow virtually all of the $600 million it expects
to save
from the job eliminations into the new sales channel, rather than trying
to
reduce overall expense levels. "The way to grow your profits over time
is
to put more on your top line," said Mr. Liddy, echoing the mantra of
Internet executives and analysts alike.
Indeed, the early investment needed to rev up a direct-sales operation
can
initially make it a far costlier form of distribution than using agents.
Companies have to spend millions on technology systems and marketing to
let customers know about the new channel.
The job cuts, which Allstate said would come from a combination of
layoffs, attrition and redeployments, will span its entire work force,
not
including agents, and will include eliminating 460 jobs from its Northbrook,
Ill., headquarters. Included in the total will be about 20 corporate officer
positions, as well as up to 200 jobs that will be lost as part of a previously
announced closing of four field offices.
Savings from the restructuring could add around three cents a share to
Allstate's earnings next year, the company estimated, and possibly 36 cents
a share in 2001. Also in an effort to improve the per-share earnings
performance, Allstate said it will double its planned share-repurchase
program to $4 billion, $1 billion of which it has already completed.
Separately, in a move that is certain to alienate some agents, Allstate
also
plans to force about 6,500 agents who are now treated as employees, with
various pension and other benefits, to become independent contractors
known as "exclusive agents."