Cluster Groups Template/Form: Difference between revisions

From Hewlett Grantees Meeting 2012
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 16: Line 16:
==Key Intended Attributes of Intervention==
==Key Intended Attributes of Intervention==


#Primary (or initial) context of intervention:  
(5) Primary (or initial) context of intervention:  
a. Formal learning
*Formal learning
b. Informal learning
*Informal learning
c. National (focus on one country)
*National (focus on one country)
d. Multinational
*Multinational


6) Primary Actors: who drives implementation?  
(6) Primary Actors: who drives implementation?  
a. Content creators
*Content creators
b. End users (teachers, learners, etc.)
*End users (teachers, learners, etc.)
c. Facilitators/intermediaries
*Facilitators/intermediaries
tool builders
*tool builders
distributors/content hosts
*distributors/content hosts
publishers  
*publishers  
schools
*schools
other: (please specify)
*other: (please specify)
d. Researchers
*Researchers
e. Policy makers
*Policy makers


7) Requires new intermediary or supporting organization?
(7) Requires new intermediary or supporting organization?
a. Can be implemented by existing organizations.
*Can be implemented by existing organizations.
b. Would require a new consortium of existing organizations
*Would require a new consortium of existing organizations
c. Would require expanded cooperation of an existing cooperative arrangement of institutions
*Would require expanded cooperation of an existing cooperative arrangement of institutions
d. Would require the creation of new organizations to implement
*Would require the creation of new organizations to implement


8) Intended Timeframe:
(8) Intended Timeframe:
a. Hackable?  i.e. able to explore, initiate or pilot with a short burst of hacking/development, including Friday’s Hackday?;
*Hackable?  i.e. able to explore, initiate or pilot with a short burst of hacking/development, including Friday’s Hackday?;
b. Short-term – reaches maturity in less than a year
*Short-term – reaches maturity in less than a year
c. Medium-term – reaches maturity in 2-4 years
*Medium-term – reaches maturity in 2-4 years
d. Long-term – reaches maturity in more than 4 years
*Long-term – reaches maturity in more than 4 years


9) Ongoing management needs - low, medium, or high?
(9)Ongoing management needs - low, medium, or high?
a. Low – little additional effort to maintain
*Low – little additional effort to maintain
b. Medium – significant ongoing effort required to maintain
*Medium – significant ongoing effort required to maintain
c. High – intensive effort to maintain
*High – intensive effort to maintain


10) Contributes to High Quality OER Supply:
(10) Contributes to High Quality OER Supply:
a. Aimed at facilitating sustainability?
*Aimed at facilitating sustainability?
b. Aimed at facilitating re-usability of OER?
*Aimed at facilitating re-usability of OER?
c. Translation component?
*Translation component?


11) Contributes to Supportive Policies:  
(11) Contributes to Supportive Policies:  
a. Requires or is focused on supporting legal and/or formal policy changes?  
*Requires or is focused on supporting legal and/or formal policy changes?  
*Focus of policy intervention:
**Institutional level
**National
**Global


b. Focus of policy intervention:
(12) Contributes to OER standards:
i. Institutional level
*Facilitates feedback and quality assessment?
ii. National
*Promotes interoperability?
iii. Global
*Promotes accessibility?
*Promotes discoverability?


12) Contributes to OER standards:
(13) Adoption & Reach:
a. Facilitates feedback and quality assessment?
*Expands audiences and increases OER adoption?
b. Promotes interoperability?
*Engages non-traditional audiences?
c. Promotes accessibility?
*Focus on community building?
d. Promotes discoverability?
*Requires significant public outreach campaign?  
*Likely to face opposition from vested interests?
*Behavioral changes or cultural shift required?


13) Adoption & Reach:
(14) Research & Evaluation:
a. Expands audiences and increases OER adoption?
*Supports evidence-gathering, data collection, impact assessment?
b. Engages non-traditional audiences?
*Requires more research and supporting information?
c. Focus on community building?
d. Requires significant public outreach campaign?
e. Likely to face opposition from vested interests?
f. Behavioral changes or cultural shift required?
 
14) Research & Evaluation:
a. Supports evidence-gathering, data collection, impact assessment?
b. Requires more research and supporting information?


==Implementation Requirements/Considerations==
==Implementation Requirements/Considerations==

Revision as of 16:40, 9 April 2012

Overview of Intervention

(1) Intervention Title

(2) Brief description of the intervention

(3) Cluster Identifier (letter)

(4)Level of intervention: Micro, meso, macro or research?

  • Micro: intervention is focused on impacting creators and users. Associated keywords: Learning & Teaching, Guidance/Training/Mentoring, Customization/Reuse/Remix/Business & Sustainability Models
  • Meso:Intervention focuses on the intermediaries, infrastructure and elements that help to link creators and end-users and contribute to building the systemic elements that facilitate the delivery, distribution and flow of OER materials. (Associated keywords: Accessibility, Tools & Technology, Search & Discoverability mechanisms, Quality Control, Accreditation, Feedback mechanisms)
  • Macro:intervention addresses broader systemic issues such as policy and legal frameworks or behavioral and cultural aspects that shape the overall OER ecosystem. (Associated keywords: Supportive Policies, Copyright & Licensing, Community Building, Lobbying)
  • Research: focus is on improving information and effort to understand the opportunities, challenges, impacts and efficacy of various OER strategies and mechanisms. (Associated keywords: Impact assessments, Evidence gathering and sharing, Case Studies)

Key Intended Attributes of Intervention

(5) Primary (or initial) context of intervention:

  • Formal learning
  • Informal learning
  • National (focus on one country)
  • Multinational

(6) Primary Actors: who drives implementation?

  • Content creators
  • End users (teachers, learners, etc.)
  • Facilitators/intermediaries
  • tool builders
  • distributors/content hosts
  • publishers
  • schools
  • other: (please specify)
  • Researchers
  • Policy makers

(7) Requires new intermediary or supporting organization?

  • Can be implemented by existing organizations.
  • Would require a new consortium of existing organizations
  • Would require expanded cooperation of an existing cooperative arrangement of institutions
  • Would require the creation of new organizations to implement

(8) Intended Timeframe:

  • Hackable? i.e. able to explore, initiate or pilot with a short burst of hacking/development, including Friday’s Hackday?;
  • Short-term – reaches maturity in less than a year
  • Medium-term – reaches maturity in 2-4 years
  • Long-term – reaches maturity in more than 4 years

(9)Ongoing management needs - low, medium, or high?

  • Low – little additional effort to maintain
  • Medium – significant ongoing effort required to maintain
  • High – intensive effort to maintain

(10) Contributes to High Quality OER Supply:

  • Aimed at facilitating sustainability?
  • Aimed at facilitating re-usability of OER?
  • Translation component?

(11) Contributes to Supportive Policies:

  • Requires or is focused on supporting legal and/or formal policy changes?
  • Focus of policy intervention:
    • Institutional level
    • National
    • Global

(12) Contributes to OER standards:

  • Facilitates feedback and quality assessment?
  • Promotes interoperability?
  • Promotes accessibility?
  • Promotes discoverability?

(13) Adoption & Reach:

  • Expands audiences and increases OER adoption?
  • Engages non-traditional audiences?
  • Focus on community building?
  • Requires significant public outreach campaign?
  • Likely to face opposition from vested interests?
  • Behavioral changes or cultural shift required?

(14) Research & Evaluation:

  • Supports evidence-gathering, data collection, impact assessment?
  • Requires more research and supporting information?

Implementation Requirements/Considerations

15) Financial requirements: low, medium, high? a. Low - can be implemented with little or no additional funding b. Medium - less than 100k per year c. High - more than 100k per year

16) Coordination needs - low, medium, or high? a. Low - able to launch without recruiting other participants b. Medium - requires coordination and buy-in of several organizations c. High - requires broad coordination/buy-in

17) Dependencies - low, medium, or high? a. Low - stand alone intervention that requires no complementary efforts; b. Medium - depends on another change/intervention; c. High - depends on several other complementary interventions/changes

18) Level of risk and uncertainty - low, medium, or high? a. Low – results are predictable b. Medium – reasonable degree of predictability c. High – results are unpredictable

19) Implementation complexity - low, medium, or high? a. Low – easy to implement b. Medium – reasonable to implement High – it is complicated c. 20) What types of innovations are required for development and implementation? (short answer)

21) Additional important considerations that have not been covered in the questions above? (short answer)